practicality: (Dante/Virgil)
Things That Make Me Happy Today:
-Not actually being late for my midterm, despite snow
-Sailor Moon Stars
-Realizing I have potatoes, cheddar cheese, and sour cream (=delicious baked potatoes)
-Pants for Rufus are almost finished!

Also, I went to see Watchmen yesterday with two friends - it was kind of interesting, because none of the three of us had read the comic, but the two of them came out with a much different opinion of the movie, I think in part because they were going in with a much different sense of what the movie was going to be. They were expecting Batman, and I was expecting V for Vendetta, and well, I was closer to being right. So they were disappointed when it wasn't a gritty action film, and I was pleased to find a rather good dystopian social commentary film. They also both thought Rorsach was the only 'cool' character - while he's certainly one of the most interesting characters in the film, dismissing everyone else as boring/weak is...kinda fucked up. Mostly because Rorsach is fucking insane and isn't in any way a hero figure (although the dichotomy is interesting - he's one of the least 'human' characters save Dr. Manhattan, but in the end, is the only one who won't compromise his beliefs). So yeah, there was some epic Missing The Point going on there, which I suspect is probably unfortunately common with this movie.

Date: 2009-03-10 04:05 pm (UTC)From: [identity profile] ext_20422 (from dreamwidth.org)
Yesyes yesssss exactly. It really bothers me how easy it is for people to blindly fanboy/fangirl Rorschach and write off everyone else; in one of my LJ friend's comment threads, they were even discussing and they were like... "Dude, the Comedian is fucked up in ways I can't wholly reconcile myself with. Not that anyone involved with that story isn't fucked up, but I can deal with Rorschach's brand of Fucked Up." && "The Comedian shot and killed a pregnant chick and raped Silk Spectre. That's enough for me to hate him forever.".

Which I think is utterly unfair (not the least because the Comedian is one of my fave characters). I don't think any character should be written off forever, particularly when you miss the point that there have been forty years since then, and he's certainly self-aware and knows about his own mistakes and regrets them and augh. I can't permanently disregard a character who understands his own fucked-up role that well.

And, now tying back into your post, I really don't think people should pardon one brand of fucked-up but not another. The movie certainly made it easier to do it, I think -- lessened some of the fucked-up things Rorschach did, increased the brutality of what the Comedian did -- but I still hate the fact that people can justify themselves into liking one psychopath, but not the other. If they can put on the empathy cap to understand one man, I think they should go the full mile to understand the rest. And not just latch onto him as your token ~action hero~.

... if I'm making any sense by now. ;_;

Date: 2009-03-10 07:52 pm (UTC)From: [identity profile] momijizukamori.dreamwidth.org
I think part of the appeal of Rorschach is that he's so different - fandom seems to love sociopaths (see: Hannibal Lecter, Seishirou Sakurazuka, Itachi, Light Yagami). And I think a key distinction needs to be made between finding characters like this fascinating, and rooting for them/identifying with them (augh I want to strangle all the Light fangirls in the world). The Comedian, on the other hand, is a very human brand of fucked up - I'm not sure I could ever truly like him (I have friends who have been sexually assaulted, so that's kind of a RUTH SMAAAASH thing for me), but I do think he presents an interesting contrast to Rorschach in the sense of 'who's the 'better' person here?' - I know a lot of people will say Rorschach, and I admire his conviction if not his methods; but on the other hand you have the Comedian, who, at the end of his life, has basically realized 'I'm what's wrong with the world', and that's very powerful, particularly as it's something none of the other characters really get.

Profile

practicality: (Default)
practicality

September 2020

S M T W T F S
  12345
6789101112
131415 16171819
20212223242526
27282930   

Most Popular Tags

Page Summary

Style Credit

  • Base style: Abstractia by chiming
  • Theme: Abyss by chiming

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jun. 16th, 2025 09:27 pm